So, that wasn’t the last you’re going to hear about the kitchen at the 10th flip. :) And now that you’ve seen what the 10th flip looks like, I think it might be a bit easier to see where we’re going with the kitchen plans.
Thanks to all of your feedback, and Sarah’s excellent suggestion of a banquette, I came up with a few new options for the kitchen floor plan (plus one that I really like but doesn’t work due to space constraints). Spoiler alert: I’ve already chosen a layout, but I still thought it would be fun to show you guys all of the options we were considering. I hope you agree!
Option 1: Banquette
I envisioned the banquette looking something like this:
I like this option a lot, because it’s a space dedicated solely to dining. However, that might be a negative in a kitchen that could be perceived as being short on storage/counter space? With this option, we’d have room to add a small counter area by the door to the laundry room – a wine fridge, kind of a beverage station area. Ooh, and we’re changing the swing of the laundry room door like many of you suggested!
Option 2: Breakfast Bar
(You may have noticed that the laundry room appears larger in this floor plan – turns out I had the wrong dimensions in my prior plans (but this one is correct), so you’ll see the size of the laundry room change from plan to plan. Sorry about that!)
This floor plan was my original thought, since the kitchen needed an eating area and a true island isn’t really an option due to the kitchen’s dimensions. The bar stools would sit on the far side of the breakfast bar (the family room side), which is actually a step down from the kitchen (the family room was originally an attached garage, but a free-standing garage has since been built on the property and the original garage was converted to living space). The breakfast bar would be counter height, but due to the difference in flooring heights you would actually need to use bar height bar stools at the counter. Does that make sense? It would be very similar to the setup below (and we could extend the cabinetry like is shown here so that the cabinets touch the family room floor, except it would be a peninsula instead of an island.
The negative with this setup is that there isn’t a ton of room for seating, so you wouldn’t be able to have casual dining for an entire family. I guess in theory you could put counter height stools on the kitchen side of the bar, but that might be strange to have two different heights of stools. (Or at least I think it would be.)
Oh, and I’m thinking of doing a surface-mount door (like a barn door)! That could be fun.
Option 3: Banquette on the other side of the kitchen
Well, hello there! I don’t know why this option didn’t occur to me sooner, but I think it addresses some of the concerns that people had with the original kitchen plan. For example, there’s now a lot of room for seating, the kitchen and family room would really flow into one another without any division, and the fridge is now next to the family room.
I think it might look a little strange to have two free-standing banks of cabinets on either side of the laundry room door (one of which is really the fridge), so I toyed with this idea of adding cabinets across the top of the doorway to connect the two sets of cabinetry, like this:
Option 4: Peninsula AND Banquette
This one was interesting to me since it provides so many options for seating. But, in the end, I think it made the kitchen kind of cramped, which is definitely something I wanted to avoid.
Option 5 (but not really): Skinny Island
I am in love with this option, BUT . . . it won’t work. On paper the measurements work, but in person the walkways feel too tight. The island pictured in the floor plan above is only 20 inches deep, which is very narrow (in comparison, kitchen cabinets are typically 24 inches deep). It might have looked strange, so maybe it’s best that the measurements are saving me from myself. :)
I envisioned it with solid sides, and a solid divider in the middle running the length of the island (so that the island wouldn’t be see-through like a table, and would look like it has more substance). Here’s kind of what I was thinking:
I think that looks awesome! Too bad. But if the measurements had worked out, since the island is so long, we could consider adding cabinets or a wine fridge at either end, running lengthwise under the island, and still have plenty of room for seating. Also, with this setup you could have bar stools on both sides of the island, which is pretty cool. But if you got rid of the divider and just closed one side of the island (probably the side by the sink and stove), you could have larger bar stools that would fit entirely under the overhang and keep the walkway a bit clearer, kind of like this (although this island is deeper than what I have in mind):
So out of all of those options, which layout do you think we chose??
Option 2!! Did you see that one coming?
I thought for sure we’d choose Option 3 – for quite some time that was the one I was leaning towards. But, in the end, I became concerned that while it may be something I would like, it might not appeal to everyone. Some people may walk in and be like, “what am I supposed to do with this thing?”, or “my great aunt Edna’s table won’t fit here”, or “I’d rather have more cabinet space” . . . or something like that.
I’m not 100% sure of our decision, but I don’t think I ever would be, so we had to make our best guess and move forward. Hopefully we made the right choice!